The proposal looked competitive.
The client was a good one. The kind you want. The work was interesting, the relationship was strong, and the opportunity felt like the right next step.
But when we put the number together, something was off.
Not in the math. The math was fine.
In the feeling that the number was too low for what this would actually take.
We overrode it.
The pressure to win the work was louder than the signal. We sharpened the pencil, absorbed the risk, and submitted a price we had already talked ourselves into believing was workable.
It wasn’t.
Six months later we were eating hours, burning out the team delivering it, and watching morale quietly erode on a file that had looked like an opportunity. The margin was gone. The goodwill was strained. And somewhere in the middle of it, I remembered that feeling in the room when we were building the proposal.
The signal was there from the beginning.
The pressure was just louder.
Your Gut Is Not the Problem
There is a growing body of research on intuition and leadership. Harvard Business Review has noted that high-level executives routinely rely on intuition when facing complex problems that resist pure analysis. Research from the Kellogg School of Management suggests that the unconscious mind excels at processing vast amounts of information simultaneously — far more than conscious analysis can handle.
Your gut instinct is not a feeling. It is your brain processing decades of pattern recognition faster than language can keep up with.
The problem is not your instinct.
The problem is what happens to it under pressure.
What Pressure Actually Does to Your Brain
When you are under sustained pressure — a role that has been open too long, a deadline bearing down, a board expecting an answer — your nervous system activates.
Harvard neuroanatomist Dr. Jill Bolte Taylor’s research shows that stress triggers a neurochemical surge through your system. Your heart rate rises. Your muscles tighten. Your field of perception narrows.
Psychologist Daniel Goleman calls the extreme version of this an Amygdala Hijack — a state where the brain’s threat detector overrides the prefrontal cortex, the part responsible for nuanced judgment, pattern recognition, and yes, reading a room.
In plain language: the more pressure you are under, the less access you have to the very intelligence you are trying to use.
The signal does not disappear. It gets quieter than the noise.
The Real Cost of Overriding It
Most leaders audit their decisions after the fact. They track the outcome and ask what went wrong.
Almost none of them track the state they were in when they made it.
The hire that didn’t work out. The partnership that felt slightly off from the start. The strategic direction that looked right on paper but never quite landed. These decisions often have one thing in common: there was a signal early. And there was pressure that made it easier to override it than to trust it.
The cost is not just the bad outcome. It is the slow erosion of trust in your own judgment. The more you override the signal, the less you believe it is worth listening to.
What to Do Before Your Next High-Stakes Decision
You cannot eliminate pressure. But you can change the state you are in when you meet it.
Before your next significant decision — a hire, a partnership, a strategic call — try this.
The 90-Second Reset
Stop (0–15s): Close what you are working on. Feet flat on the floor. Fully disconnect from the momentum of the day.
Regulate (15–45s): Inhale for a count of four. Exhale for a count of eight. The longer exhale activates your vagus nerve and signals your nervous system to downshift from alert mode.
Audit (45–75s): Ask yourself: what am I actually carrying into this decision right now? Urgency? Fear of getting it wrong? Pressure to fill the seat? Name it. Dr. Daniel Siegel’s research shows that naming an emotional state reduces its neurological grip — what he calls “name it to tame it.”
Release (75–90s): Set that load down. Not permanently. Just for this moment. You are not ignoring the pressure. You are choosing the state from which you meet it.
Now ask: what does the signal say?
Not the data. Not the opinions. Not the urgency.
The signal.
The Signal Was Never Wrong
In my years in Risk Advisory at KPMG, we were trained to identify the variables most likely to compromise decision quality. We built frameworks around them. We stress-tested assumptions.
What we never measured was the internal state of the person making the call.
That is what I do now. And what I have learned, working with leaders under pressure, is consistent:
The gut is rarely wrong.
The state it is operating from is the variable.
If you want to understand where pressure is interfering with your judgment, the Decision Clarity Scan takes five minutes and shows you exactly where the interference is. →Get it here
Every Wednesday I send The Clarity Brief — short, practical insights on decision-making and performance under pressure. No fluff. →Subscribe here : The Clarity Brief
Discover more from Reflections
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Reflections 